The impact of procurement method on costs of procurement
Hughes, W., Hillebrandt, P. and Greenwood, D. (2005) The impact of procurement method on costs of procurement. In: Combining Forces, Advancing Facilities Management and Construction through Innovation, Helsinki, pp. 214-226.
Collaborative working methods offer the hope of reduced waste, lower tendering costs and improved outputs. The costs of tendering may be influenced by the introduction of different working methods. Transaction cost economics appears to offer an analytical framework for studying the costs of tendering, but it is more to do with providing explanations at the institutional/industry level, not at the level of individual projects. Surveys and interviews were carried out with small samples in UK. The data show that that while tendering costs are not necessarily higher in collaborative working arrangements, there is no correlation between costs of tendering and the way the work is organized. Practitioners perceive that the benefits of working in collaborative procurement routes far outweigh the costs. Tendering practices can be improved to avoid waste, and the suggested improvements include restricting selective tendering lists to 23 bidders, letting bidders know who they are competing with, reimbursing tendering costs for aborted projects and ensuring that timely and comprehensive information is provided to bidders.
 Hughes, W.P., Hillebrandt, P., Lingard, H. and Greenwood, D. (2001) The impact of market and supply configurations on the costs of tendering in the construction industry. In: Duncan, J. (ed) Procs CIB World Building Congress, April 2001, Wellington New Zealand, 2, pp73-78.  Hughes, W.P., Hillebrandt, P.M., Greenwood, D.J., Kwawu, W.E.K. (2002) Developing a system for assessing the costs associated with different procurement routes in the construction industry. In: Uwakweh, B.O. (ed) Procs CIB W65 on Organization and Management in Construction. September 2002, Cincinnati.  Hughes, W.P. (2003) Comparative costs of the commercial process in different construction procurement methods. In: Ofori, G. (ed) Procs Joint International Symposium of CIB Working Commissions: Construction in Developing Countries. October 2003, Singapore.  Coase, R H (1937) The nature of the firm. Economica. 4, 386-405.  Williamson, O E (1990) The firm as a nexus of treaties: an introduction. In: Aoki M, Gustafsson B and Williamson O E (eds), The firm as a nexus of treaties. Sage London.  Eccles R G (1981) The quasifirm in the construction industry. Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization, 5, 335-357.  Pitelis C (1993) Transaction costs, markets and hierarchies. Blackwell, Oxford.  Holmstrom B R and J Tirole (1989) The theory of the firm. In: R Schmalensee and R D Willig (Eds) Handbook of industrial organization. Vol 1. Elsevier Science Publishers, Amsterdam.  Reve T and R E Levitt (1984) Organization and governance in construction. Int. J. of Project Management. 2, 17-25.  Winch G (1989) The construction firm and the construction project: a transaction cost approach. Construction Management and Economics. 7, 331345.  Reve T (1990) The firm as a nexus of internal and external contracts. In: Aoki M., Gustafsson B. and Williamson O.E. (eds), The firm as a nexus of treaties. Sage, London.  Casson M. (1994) Why are firms hierarchical? Journal of the Economics of Business, 1, 4776.  Winch G (1995) Project management in construction: towards a transaction cost approach. Le Groupe Bagnolet, Working Paper 1. University College, London.  Lyons B.R. (1995) Specific investment, economies of scale, and the makeorbuy decision: a test of transaction cost theory, Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization, 26, 431-443.  Dutta S and G John (1995) Combining laboratory experiments and industry data in transaction cost analysis: the case of completion as a safeguard. Journal of Law, Economics and Organization. 11, 87-111.  Dietrich M (1994) Transaction cost economics and beyond. Routledge, London.  Buckley, P J and P Enderwick (1989) Manpower management. In: P Hillebrandt and J Cannon (eds) The British construction firm. London: Macmillan.  Hillebrandt, P M and J Cannon (1990) The modern construction firm. London: Macmillan  Hillebrandt, P M (1984) Analysis of the British construction industry. London: Macmillan.  Lemessany, J and M A Clapp (1975) Resource inputs to new construction: the labour requirements of hospital building CP 85/75. Watford: Building Research Establishment.  Williamson, O E (1975) Markets and hierarchies: analysis and antitrust implications: a study in the economics of internal organization. The Free Press, London.  Lingard H, W P Hughes and E Chinyio (1998) The impact of contractor selection method on transaction costs: a review. Journal of Construction Procurement. 4, 89-102.  Gruneberg S L and G Ive (2000) The economics of the modern construction firm. London: Macmillan.  Hughes, W P and P M Hillebrandt (2003) Construction industry: historical overview and technological change. In: J Mokyr (ed.in.chief) The Oxford Encyclopedia of Economic History, Oxford: Oxford University Press, Vol 1, 504-512.  Murray, M and D Langford (eds) (2003) Construction reports 194498.Oxford: Blackwell.  Chang, C Y and G Ive (2001) A comparison of two ways of applying a transaction cost approach: The case of construction procurement routes. In: Bartlett Research papers, No. 13, 41pp.  Masden, S E, J W Meehan, and E A Snyder (1991) The costs of organization. Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 7(1), 125.  Matthews, J, A Tyler and A Thorpe (1996) Preconstruction project partnering: Developing the process. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 3(1/2), 117-31.  Pasquire, C L and S Collins (1996) The effect of competitive tendering on value in construction. RICS Research Papers, 2(5), 132.  Hillebrandt, P M (2000) Economic theory and the construction industry. 3ed. London, Macmillan.  Flanagan, R and G Norman (1989) 'Pricing Policy', In: P M Hillebrandt and J Cannon (eds), The management of construction firms: aspects of theory. London: Macmillan  Egan, J (1998) Rethinking Construction: The report of the construction task force (The Egan Report), Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, London: HMSO.  Cook, A E (1990) The cost of preparing tenders for fixed price contracts. Technical Information Service. P. Harlow (Ed). Ascot, Chartered Institute of Building: 17.  Grimsey, D and R Graham (1997) PFI in the NHS (private finance initiative in the UK national health service). Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 4(3), 215-31.
Repository Staff Only: item control page