Navigating the protein transition: why dairy and its matrix matter amid rising plant protein trends
Witard, O. C., Devrim-Lampir, A., McKinley, M. C. and Givens, D. I.
It is advisable to refer to the publisher's version if you intend to cite from this work. See Guidance on citing. To link to this item DOI: 10.1017/S0954422425000101 Abstract/SummaryThe concept of the protein transition represents a shift from a diet rich in animal proteins to one richer in plant-based alternatives, largely in response to environmental sustainability concerns. However, a simple swap by replacing dairy protein with plant protein will lead to lower protein quality and a lower intake of key micronutrients that sit naturally within the dairy matrix. Owing to antagonistic effects within the plant food matrix, micronutrients in plant sources exhibit lower bioavailability which is not reflected in food composition data or dietary guidelines. The dairy matrix effect includes moderation of blood lipid levels in which calcium plays a key role. Protein recommendations often take a muscle-centric approach. Hence, strategies to increase the anabolic potential of plant proteins have focused on increasing total protein intake to counter the suboptimal amino acid composition relative to dairy protein or leucine fortification. However, emerging evidence indicates a role for nutrient interactions and non-nutrient components (milk exosomes, bioactive peptides) of the dairy matrix in modulating postprandial muscle protein synthesis rates. To ensure food system transformation is environmentally sustainable and optimal from a nutrition perspective, consideration needs to be given to complementary benefits of different food matrices and the holistic evaluation of foods in the protein transition. This narrative review critically examines the role of dairy in the protein transition, emphasizing the importance of the food matrix in nutrient bioavailability and muscle health. By considering both nutritional and sustainability perspectives, we provide a holistic evaluation of dairy’s contribution within evolving dietary patterns.
• Fardet A, Rock E. Toward a new philosophy of preventive nutrition: from a reductionist to a holistic paradigm to improve nutritional recommendations. Adv Nutr 2014; 5(4): 430–446.
• Messina M et al. Reductionism and the narrowing nutrition perspective: time for reevaluation and emphasis on food synergy. J Am Diet Assoc 2001; 101(12): 1416–1419.
• Hoffmann I. Transcending reductionism in nutrition research. Am J Clin Nutr 2003; 78(3 Suppl): 514S–516S.
• Geiker NRW et al. Impact of whole dairy matrix on musculoskeletal health and aging-current knowledge and research gaps. Osteoporos Int 2020; 31(4): 601–615.
• Thorning TK et al. Whole dairy matrix or single nutrients in assessment of health effects: current evidence and knowledge gaps. Am J Clin Nutr 2017; 105(5): 1033–1045.
• Feeney EL, McKinley MC. Chapter 8 - The dairy food matrix: What it is and what it does. In: Givens DI, ed. Milk and Dairy Foods: Academic Press, 2020.
• Liu F et al. How food matrices modulate folate bioaccessibility: A comprehensive overview of recent advances and challenges. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf 2024; 23(3): e13328–4337.13328.
• Espersen R et al. Influence of food matrix delivery system on the bioavailability of vitamin D(3): A randomized crossover trial in postmenopausal women. Nutrition 2023; 107: 111911.
• van Vliet S et al. Consumption of whole eggs promotes greater stimulation of postexercise muscle protein synthesis than consumption of isonitrogenous amounts of egg whites in young men. Am J Clin Nutr 2017; 106(6): 1401–1412.
• Grundy MM et al. A review of the impact of processing on nutrient bioaccessibility and digestion of almonds. Int J Food Sci Technol 2016; 51(9): 1937–1946.
• Weaver CM. Dairy matrix: is the whole greater than the sum of the parts? Nutr Rev 2021; 79(Suppl 2): 4–15.
• Duluins O, Baret PV. A systematic review of the definitions, narratives and paths forwards for a protein transition in high-income countries. Nat Food 2024; 5(1): 28–36.
• Duluins O, Baret PV. The paradoxes of the protein transition maintain existing animal production and consumption systems. Nat Food 2024.
• NDNS. National Diet and Nutrition Survey Rolling programme, Years 9 to 11 (2016/2017 to 2018/2019). A survey carried out on behalf of Public Health England and the Food Standards Agency. 2020.
• Dairy UK The Nutritional Composition of Dairy Products. [online]. , 2021. https://milk.co.uk/nutritional-composition-of-dairy/ 2021).
• 16. Pellinen T et al. Replacing dietary animal-source proteins with plant-source proteins changes dietary intake and status of vitamins and minerals in healthy adults: a 12-week randomized controlled trial. Eur J Nutr 2022; 61(3): 1391–1404.
• 17. FAO. Dietary protein quality evaluation in human nutrition: Report of an FAO expert consultation.
• 18. Moore SS et al. Nutritional scores of milk- and plant-based alternatives and their difference in contribution to human nutrition. . LWT - Food Sci Technol (191): 1156–1188.
• 19. Walsh MC, Gunn C. Non-dairy milk substitutes: Are they of adequate nutritional composition? In: Given DI, ed. In Milk and Dairy foods: Their Functionality in Human Health and DiseaseI Cambridge, CA: Elsevier, 2020: 374–369.
• 20. McAuliffe GA et al. Protein quality as a complementary functional unit in life cycle assessment (LCA). Int J Life Cycle Assess 2023; 28(2): 146–155.
• 21. Givens DI. MILK Symposium review: The importance of milk and dairy foods in the diets of infants, adolescents, pregnant women, adults, and the elderly. J Dairy Sci 2020; 103(11): 9681–9699.
• 22. Larson NI et al. Calcium and dairy intake: Longitudinal trends during the transition to young adulthood and correlates of calcium intake. J Nutr Educ Behav 2009; 41(4): 254–260.
• 23. Parker CE et al. Changes in dairy food and nutrient intakes in Australian adolescents. Nutrients 2012; 4(12): 1794–1811.
• 24. Givens DI. Animal board invited review: Dietary transition from animal to plant-derived foods: Are there risks to health? Animal 2024; 18(9): 101263.
• 25. Willett W et al. Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT-Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems. Lancet 2019; 393(10170): 447–492.
• 26. Beal T et al. Estimated micronutrient shortfalls of the EAT-Lancet planetary health diet. Lancet Planet Health 2023; 7(3): e233–e237.
• 27. Shkembi B, Huppertz T. Calcium absorption from food products: Food matrix effects. Nutrients 2021; 14(1): 180.
• 28. Ravindran G. Studies on millets: Proximate composition, mineral composition, and phytate and oxalate contents. Food Chem 2000; 39: 99–107.
• 29. Lonnerdal B. Dietary factors influencing zinc absorption. J Nutr 2000; 130(5S Suppl): 1378S–83S.
• 30. Vogiatzoglou A et al. Dietary sources of vitamin B-12 and their association with plasma vitamin B-12 concentrations in the general population: the Hordaland Homocysteine Study. Am J Clin Nutr 2009; 89(4): 1078–1087.
• 31. Bijl E et al. Protein, casein, and micellar salts in milk: current content and historical perspectives. J Dairy Sci 2013; 96(9): 5455–5464.
• 32. Grewal MK et al. Influence of calcium and magnesium on the secondary structure in solutions of individual and binary casein mixtures. Int Dairy J 2020; 112: 1048–1079.
• 33. Muleya M et al. A comparison of the bioaccessible calcium supplies of various plant-based products relative to bovine milk. Food Res Int 2024; 175: 1137–1195.
• 34. Brodkorb A et al. INFOGEST static in vitro simulation of gastrointestinal food digestion. Nat Protoc 2019; 14(4): 991–1014.
• 35. Moore SS et al. How animal milk and plant-based alternatives diverge in terms of fatty acid, amino acid, and mineral composition. NPJ Sci Food 2023; 7(1): 50–55.
• 36. Cashman KD et al. Adolescence and acquisition of peak bone mass. In: Anon.In Feldman and Pike’s Vitamin D 5th Edition, Volume One: Biochemistry, Physiology and Diagnostics Cambridge MA: Academic Press: 801–829.
• 37. Weaver CM et al. The National Osteoporosis Foundation's position statement on peak bone mass development and lifestyle factors: a systematic review and implementation recommendations. Osteoporos Int 2016; 27(4): 1281–1386.
• 38. Baker C, Benayoun BA. Menopause Is More Than Just Loss of Fertility. Public Policy Aging Rep 2023; 33(4): 113–119.
• 39. Dominguez LJ et al. Association between Serum Magnesium and Fractures: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies. Nutrients 2023; 15(6): 1304. doi: 10.3390/nu15061304.
• 40. Uwitonze AM, Razzaque MS. Role of Magnesium in Vitamin D Activation and Function. J Am Osteopath Assoc 2018; 118(3): 181–189.
• 41. Cashman KD et al. Vitamin D deficiency in Europe: pandemic? Am J Clin Nutr 2016; 103(4): 1033–1044.
• 42. Iguacel I et al. Veganism, vegetarianism, bone mineral density, and fracture risk: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Nutr Rev 2019; 77(1): 1–18.
• 43. Tong TYN et al. Vegetarian and vegan diets and risks of total and site-specific fractures: results from the prospective EPIC-Oxford study. BMC Med 2020; 18(1): 353–3.
• 44. Bath SC et al. Iodine deficiency in pregnant women living in the South East of the UK: the influence of diet and nutritional supplements on iodine status. Br J Nutr 2014; 111(9): 1622–1631.
• 45. Vanderpump MPJ et al. Iodine status of UK schoolgirls: a cross-sectional survey. Lancet 2011; 377(9782): 2007–2012.
• 46. Bath SC, Rayman MP. A review of the iodine status of UK pregnant women and its implications for the offspring. Environ Geochem Health 2015; 37(4): 619–629.
• 47. Mullan K et al. Iodine status of teenage girls on the island of Ireland. Eur J Nutr 2020; 59(5): 1859–1867.
• 48. Pawlak R et al. Prevalence and Predictors of Low Breast Milk Iodine Concentration in Women Following Vegan, Vegetarian, and Omnivore Diets. Breastfeed Med 2023; 18(1): 37–42.
• 49. Perrin MT et al. Major and trace mineral composition of milk from lactating women following vegan, vegetarian and omnivore diets. Br J Nutr 2023; 130(6): 1005–1012.
• 50. Mansilla R et al. Detecting iodine deficiency risks from dietary transitions using shopping data. Sci Rep 2024; 14(1): 1017–7.
• 51. Bath SC. The effect of iodine deficiency during pregnancy on child development. Proc Nutr Soc 2019; 78(2): 150–160.
• 52. Sukumar N et al. Vitamin B12 status in women of childbearing age in the UK and its relationship with national nutrient intake guidelines: results from two National Diet and Nutrition Surveys. BMJ Open 2016; 6(8): e011247–011247.
• 53. NICE. How should I interpret investigation results? 2024.
• 54. Scott JM, Molloy AM. The discovery of vitamin B(12). Ann Nutr Metab 2012; 61(3): 239–245.
• 55. Ray JG et al. Vitamin B12 and the risk of neural tube defects in a folic-acid-fortified population. Epidemiology 2007; 18(3): 362–366.
• 56. Molloy AM et al. Maternal vitamin B12 status and risk of neural tube defects in a population with high neural tube defect prevalence and no folic Acid fortification. Pediatrics 2009; 123(3): 917–923.
• 57. Givens DI et al. Anaemia in India and Its Prevalence and Multifactorial Aetiology: A Narrative Review. Nutrients 2024; 16(11): 1673. doi: 10.3390/nu16111673.
• 58. Givens DI. Dairy foods and cardiometabolic diseases: an update and a reassessment of the impact of SFA. Proc Nutr Soc 2023; 82(3): 329–345.
• 59. de Oliveira Otto MC et al. Dietary intake of saturated fat by food source and incident cardiovascular disease: the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis. Am J Clin Nutr 2012; 96(2): 397–404.
• 60. Vissers LET et al. Fatty acids from dairy and meat and their association with risk of coronary heart disease. Eur J Nutr 2019; 58(7): 2639–2647.
• 61. Vogtschmidt YD et al. Replacement of Saturated Fatty Acids from Meat by Dairy Sources in Relation to Incident Cardiovascular Disease: The European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC)-Norfolk Study. Am J Clin Nutr 2024; 119(6): 1495–1503.
• 62. Bechthold A et al. Food groups and risk of coronary heart disease, stroke and heart failure: A systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis of prospective studies. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 2019; 59(7): 1071–1090.
• 63. Mozaffarian D. Dietary and Policy Priorities for Cardiovascular Disease, Diabetes, and Obesity: A Comprehensive Review. Circulation 2016; 133(2): 187–225.
• 64. Soerensen KV et al. Effect of dairy calcium from cheese and milk on fecal fat excretion, blood lipids, and appetite in young men. Am J Clin Nutr 2014; 99(5): 984–991.
• 65. Lorenzen JK, Astrup A. Dairy calcium intake modifies responsiveness of fat metabolism and blood lipids to a high-fat diet. Br J Nutr 2011; 105(12): 1823–1831.
• 66. Vaskonen T. Dietary minerals and modification of cardiovascular risk factors. J Nutr Biochem 2003; 14(9): 492–506.
• 67. Bosworth AW et al. The digestion and absorption of fats. 1. Calcium in relation to the absorption of fatty acids. Am J Dis Child 1918; 15: 397–407.
• 68. Lamothe S et al. Influence of dairy matrices on nutrient release in a simulated gastrointestinal environment. Food Res Int 2017; 92: 138–146.
• 69. O’Connor A et al. An examination of the impact of unmelted, melted, and deconstructed cheese on lipid metabolism: a 6-week randomised trial. Food Funct 2024; 15: 834–835.
• 70. Sayer AA et al. New horizons in the pathogenesis, diagnosis and management of sarcopenia. Age Ageing 2013; 42(2): 145–150.
• 71. Wolfe RR. The underappreciated role of muscle in health and disease. Am.J.Clin.Nutr. 2006; 84: 475–482.
• 72. Cermak NM et al. Protein supplementation augments the adaptive response of skeletal muscle to resistance-type exercise training: a meta-analysis. Am J Clin Nutr 2012; 96(6): 1454–1464.
• 73. Burd NA et al. Dietary Protein Quantity, Quality, and Exercise Are Key to Healthy Living: A Muscle-Centric Perspective Across the Lifespan. Front Nutr 2019; 6: 83.
• 74. Moore DR et al. Protein Ingestion to Stimulate Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis Requires Greater Relative Protein Intakes in Healthy Older Versus Younger Men. J.Gerontol.A Biol.Sci.Med.Sci. 2014.
• 75. Phillips SM et al. Dietary protein to support anabolism with resistance exercise in young men. J.Am.Coll.Nutr. 2005; 24: 134S–139S.
• 76. Gorissen SHM, Witard OC. Characterising the muscle anabolic potential of dairy, meat and plant-based protein sources in older adults. Proc Nutr Soc 2018; 77(1): 20–31.
• 77. Witard OC et al. Dairy as a Source of Iodine and Protein in the UK: Implications for Human Health Across the Life Course, and Future Policy and Research. Front Nutr 2022; 9: 800559.
• 78. Tang JE et al. Ingestion of whey hydrolysate, casein, or soy protein isolate: effects on mixed muscle protein synthesis at rest and following resistance exercise in young men. J Appl Physiol 2009; 107: 987–992.
• 79. Burd NA et al. Greater stimulation of myofibrillar protein synthesis with ingestion of whey protein isolate v. micellar casein at rest and after resistance exercise in elderly men. Br.J.Nutr. 2012: 1–5.
• 80. Gorissen SHM et al. The muscle protein synthetic response to food ingestion. Meat Sci 2015; 109: 96–100.
• 81. van Vliet S et al. The skeletal muscle anabolic response to plant- versus animal-based protein consumption. J Nutr 2015; Ahead of print.
• 82. Gorissen SH et al. Ingestion of Wheat Protein Increases In Vivo Muscle Protein Synthesis Rates in Healthy Older Men in a Randomized Trial. J Nutr 2016; 146(9): 1651–1659.
• 83. Wall BT et al. Leucine co-ingestion improves post-prandial muscle protein accretion in elderly men. Clin.Nutr. 2013; 32: 412–419.
• 84. Norton LE et al. The leucine content of a complete meal directs peak activation but not duration of skeletal muscle protein synthesis and mammalian target of rapamycin signaling in rats. J.Nutr. 2009; 139: 1103–1109.
• 85. Pinckaers PJM et al. The Muscle Protein Synthetic Response to the Ingestion of a Plant-Derived Protein Blend Does Not Differ from an Equivalent Amount of Milk Protein in Healthy Young Males. J Nutr 2023; 152(12): 2734–2743.
• 86. Pinckaers PJM et al. No differences in muscle protein synthesis rates following ingestion of wheat protein, milk protein, and their protein blend in healthy, young males. Br J Nutr 2021; 126(12): 1832–1842.
• 87. Kouw IWK et al. Ingestion of an ample amount of meat substitute based on a lysine-enriched, plant-based protein blend stimulates postprandial muscle protein synthesis to a similar extent as an isonitrogenous amount of chicken in healthy, young men. Br J Nutr 2021: 1–11.
• 88. Phillips SM et al. Commonly consumed protein foods contribute to nutrient intake, diet quality, and nutrient adequacy. Am.J.Clin.Nutr. 2015: 101(6): 1346S-1352S.
• 89. Burd NA et al. Food-First Approach to Enhance the Regulation of Post-exercise Skeletal Muscle Protein Synthesis and Remodeling. Sports Med 2019; 49(Suppl 1): 59–68.
• 90. Wilkinson SB et al. Consumption of fluid skim milk promotes greater muscle protein accretion after resistance exercise than does consumption of an isonitrogenous and isoenergetic soy-protein beverage. Am.J.Clin.Nutr. 2007; 85: 1031–1040.
• 91. Hermans WJH et al. Cheese Ingestion Increases Muscle Protein Synthesis Rates Both at Rest and During Recovery from Exercise in Healthy, Young Males: A Randomized Parallel-Group Trial. J Nutr 2022; 152(4): 1022–1030.
• 92. Hermans WJ et al. Acute Quark Ingestion Increases Muscle Protein Synthesis Rates at Rest with a Further Increase after Exercise in Young and Older Adult Males in a Parallel-Group Intervention Trial. J Nutr 2023; 153(1): 66–75.
• 93. Symons TB et al. A moderate serving of high-quality protein maximally stimulates skeletal muscle protein synthesis in young and elderly subjects. J.Am.Diet.Assoc. 2009; 109: 1582–1586.
• 94. Paulussen KJ et al. Underpinning the Food Matrix Regulation of Postexercise Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis by Comparing Salmon Ingestion With the Sum of Its Isolated Nutrients in Healthy Young Adults. J Nutr 2023; 153(5): 1359–1372.
• 95. Burd NA et al. Differences in postprandial protein handling after beef compared with milk ingestion during postexercise recovery: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr 2015; 102(4): 828–836.
• 96. Mitchell CJ et al. Consumption of Milk Protein or Whey Protein Results in a Similar Increase in Muscle Protein Synthesis in Middle Aged Men. Nutrients 2015; 7(10): 8685–8699.
• 97. Churchward-Venne T et al. Ingestion of Casein in a Milk Matrix Modulates Dietary Protein Digestion and Absorption Kinetics but Does Not Modulate Postprandial Muscle Protein Synthesis in Older Men. J Nutr 2015; 145(7): 1438–1445.
• 98. Weijzen MEG et al. Ingestion of Free Amino Acids Compared with an Equivalent Amount of Intact Protein Results in More Rapid Amino Acid Absorption and Greater Postprandial Plasma Amino Acid Availability Without Affecting Muscle Protein Synthesis Rates in Young Adults in a Double-Blind Randomized Trial. J Nutr 2022; 152(1): 59–67.
• 99. Zaromskyte G et al. Evaluating the Leucine Trigger Hypothesis to Explain the Post-prandial Regulation of Muscle Protein Synthesis in Young and Older Adults: A Systematic Review. Front Nutr 2021; 8: 685165.
• 100. Wilkinson K et al. Association of postprandial postexercise muscle protein synthesis rates with dietary leucine: A systematic review. Physiol Rep 2023; 11(15): e15775.
• 101. Monteyne AJ et al. Reconsidering the pre-eminence of dietary leucine and plasma leucinemia for predicting the stimulation of postprandial muscle protein synthesis rates. Am J Clin Nutr 2024; 120(1): 7–16.
• 102. Elliot TA et al. Milk ingestion stimulates net muscle protein synthesis following resistance exercise. Med.Sci.Sports Exerc. 2006; 38: 667–674.
• 103. Nyakayiru J et al. The glycation level of milk protein strongly modulates post-prandial lysine availability in humans. Br J Nutr 2020; 123(5): 545–552.
• 104. Yamada T et al. Comparison of methods for isolating exosomes from bovine milk. J Vet Med Sci 2012; 74(11): 1523–1525.
• 105. Izumi H et al. Bovine milk contains microRNA and messenger RNA that are stable under degradative conditions. J Dairy Sci 2012; 95(9): 4831–4841.
• 106. Izumi H et al. Bovine milk exosomes contain microRNA and mRNA and are taken up by human macrophages. J Dairy Sci 2015; 98(5): 2920–2933.
• 107. Hata T et al. Isolation of bovine milk-derived microvesicles carrying mRNAs and microRNAs. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 2010; 396(2): 528–533.
• 108. Meng Z et al. Human milk extracellular vesicles enhance muscle growth and physical performance of immature mice associating with Akt/mTOR/p70s6k signaling pathway. J Nanobiotechnology 2023; 21(1): 304–6.
• 109. Mobley CB et al. Whey protein-derived exosomes increase protein synthesis and hypertrophy in C(2-)C(12) myotubes. J Dairy Sci 2017; 100(1): 48–64.
• 110. Morifuji M et al. Comparison of different sources and degrees of hydrolysis of dietary protein: effect on plasma amino acids, dipeptides, and insulin responses in human subjects. J Agric Food Chem 2010; 58(15): 8788–8797.
• 111. Wang T et al. Vegetarian and vegan diets: benefits and drawbacks. Eur Heart J ; 44: 3423–3439.
• 112. Miller KA et al. Proximate composition and anti-nutritional factors of fava bean (Vicia faba), green-pea and yellow-pea (Pisum sativum) flour. 2019; 82: 1032–1033.
• 113. Pinchen H et al. McCance and Widdowson’s The Composition of Foods Integrated Dataset (CoFID). 2021.
• 114. Herreman L et al. Comprehensive overview of the quality of plant- And animal-sourced proteins based on the digestible indispensable amino acid score. Food Sci Nutr 2020; 8(10): 5379–5391.
• 115. Nosworthy MG et al. Effect of Processing on the In Vitro and In Vivo Protein Quality of Beans (Phaseolus vulgaris and Vicia Faba). Nutrients 2018; 10(6): 671. University Staff: Request a correction | Centaur Editors: Update this record |