Shame on who? The effects of corporate irresponsibility and social performance on organizational reputationNardella, G., Brammer, S. and Surdu, I. (2020) Shame on who? The effects of corporate irresponsibility and social performance on organizational reputation. British Journal of Management, 31 (1). pp. 5-23. ISSN 1467-8551
It is advisable to refer to the publisher's version if you intend to cite from this work. See Guidance on citing. To link to this item DOI: 10.1111/1467-8551.12365 Abstract/SummaryThis study examines the relationship between corporate irresponsibility, corporate social performance and changes in organizational reputation. By combining attribution theory with expectancy violations theory, we provide the first systematic analysis of how organizational reputations are influenced by attributions of corporate irresponsibility in the context of social expectations. Drawing on a comprehensive and unique corporate irresponsibility dataset, this study reveals that firms previously believed to be most socially responsible are penalized by evaluators when corporate culpability is verified by a court of law. Conversely, firms perceived as least socially responsible were more likely to suffer reputation penalties when accused of irresponsibility, without their culpability established through litigation. Overall, the results of our study suggest that organizational reputations are mostly stable in light of irresponsibility, in that evaluators only penalize certain firms, in certain circumstances. Specifically, reputation penalties occur when highly responsible firms are perceived hypocritical and least responsible firms were not found culpable by a court of law. Upon reflection of these findings, our study reveals that the mechanisms of social sanction previously assumed to regulate irresponsibility are weaker than currently understood. Theoretical and policy implications of this study are discussed, along with directions for future research on social evaluations.
DownloadsDownloads per month over past year
Aguilera, R.V., D. E. Rupp, C. A. Williams and J. Ganapathi, (2007). 'Putting the S back in corporate social responsibility: A multilevel theory of social change in organizations'. Academy of Management Review, 32, pp. 836-863.
Alicke, M. D. (2000). 'Culpable control and the psychology of blame'. Psychological Bulletin, 126, pp. 556- 574.
Alexander, C. R. (1999). 'On the nature of the reputational penalty for corporate crime: Evidence'. Journal of Law and Economics, 42, pp. 489-526.
Antonetti, P. and M. Anesa (2017). ‘Consumer reactions to corporate tax strategies. The role of political ideology’. Journal of Business Research, 74, 1–10.
Antonetti, P. and S. Maklan (2016). 'Social identification and corporate irresponsibility: A model of stakeholder punitive intentions'. British Journal of Management, 27, pp. 583-605.
Appiah, K. A. (2009). ‘Experiments in ethics’. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Bailey, A. A. and C. M. Bonifield (2010). 'Broken (promotional) promises: The impact of firm reputation and blame'. Journal of Marketing Communications, 16, pp. 287-306.
Barnett, M. L. and R. M. Salomon (2012). ‘Does it pay to be really good? addressing the shape of the relationship between social and financial performance’. Strategic Management Journal, 33, pp. 1304- 1320.
Bitektine, A. (2011). 'Toward a theory of social judgments of organizations: The case of legitimacy, reputation, and status'. Academy of Management Review, 36, pp. 151-179.
Brammer, S. J. and A. Millington (2004). 'The development of corporate charitable contributions in the UK: A stakeholder analysis'. Journal of Management Studies, 41, pp. 1411-1434.
Brammer, S. J. and S. Pavelin (2005). 'Corporate reputation and an insurance motivation for corporate social investment'. The Journal of Corporate Citizenship, 20, pp. 39-51.
Brammer, S. J. and S. Pavelin (2006). 'Corporate reputation and social performance: The importance of fit'. Journal of Management Studies, 43, pp. 435-455.
Brammer, S. J., G. Jackson and D. Matten (2012). 'Corporate social responsibility and institutional theory: New perspectives on private governance.' Socio-Economic Review, 10, pp. 3-28.
Bundy, J. and M. D. Pfarrer (2015). 'A burden of responsibility: The role of social approval at the onset of a crisis'. Academy of Management Review, 40, pp. 345-369.
Burgoon, J. K. (1978). 'A communication model of personal space violations: Explication and an initial test'. Human Communication Research, 4, pp. 129-142.
Campbell, J. L. (2007). 'Why would corporations behave in socially responsible ways? An institutional theory of corporate social responsibility'. Academy of Management Review, 32, pp. 946-967.
Carlos, W. C. and B. W. Lewis (2018). ‘Strategic Silence: Withholding certification status as a hypocrisy avoidance tactic’. Administrative Science Quarterly, 63, pp. 130-169.
Carroll, C. E. and M. McCombs (2003). ‘Agenda-setting effects of business news on the public’s images and opinions about major corporations’. Corporate Reputation Review, 6, pp. 36-46.
Choi, Y. and Y. H. Lin (2009). ‘Consumer responses to Mattel product recalls posted on online bulletin boards: Exploring two types of emotion’. Journal of Public Relations Research, 21, pp. 198-207.
Claeys, A.S., V. Cauberghe and P. Vyncke (2010). Restoring reputations in times of crisis: An experimental study of the Situational Crisis Communication Theory and the moderating effects of locus of control. Public Relations Review. 36, pp. 256-262.
De Cremer, D., R. van Dick, A. Tenbrunsel, M. Pillutla and K. J. Murnighan (2011). ‘Understanding ethical behavior and decision making in management: A behavioural business ethics approach’. British Journal of Management, 22, pp. S1-S4.
De Jong, M. D. T. and M. van der Meer (2017). ‘How does it fit? Exploring the congruence between organizations and their corporate social responsibility (CSR) activities’. Journal of Business Ethics, 143, pp. 71–83.
Deephouse, D. and P. Heugens (2009). 'Linking social issues to organizational impact: The role of infomediaries and the infomediary process'. Journal of Business Ethics, 86, pp. 541–553.
Donaldson, T. and T. Dunfee (1999). 'Ties that bind: A social contracts approach to business ethics'. Boston: Harvard University Press.
Ducassy, I. (2013). 'Does corporate social responsibility pay off in times of crisis? An alternate perspective on the relationship between financial and corporate social performance'. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 20, pp. 157-167.
Fiske, S. T. and S. E. Taylor (1991). 'Social cognition'. (2nd ed.) New York: McGraw-Hill.
Flanagan, D. J. and K. C. O’Shaughnessy (2005). 'The effect of layoffs on firm reputation'. Journal of Management, 31, pp. 445-463.
Fombrun, C. J. and V. Rindova (1996). 'Who’s tops and who decides? The social construction of corporate reputations’, New York University, Stern School of Business, Working Paper.
Fombrun, C. and M. Shanley (1990). ‘What’s in a name? Reputation building and corporate strategy’. Academy of Management Journal, 33, pp. 233–258.
Flammer, C. (2013). 'Corporate social responsibility and shareholder reaction: The environmental awareness of investors'. Academy of Management Journal, 56, pp. 758–781.
Godfrey, P. (2005). 'The relationship between community investments and shareholder wealth'. Academy of Management Review, 30, pp. 777-798.
Grappi, S., S. Romani and R. P. Bagozzi (2013). 'Consumer response to corporate irresponsible behavior: The role of moral emotions and virtues'. Journal of Business Research, 66, pp. 1814–1821.
Haidt, J. and F. Bjorklund (2008). 'Social intuitionists answer six questions about morality'. In W. Sinnott- Armstrong (Eds.), Moral psychology. Volume 2: The cognitive science of morality, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp. 181–217.
He, X., J. Pittman and O. M. Rui. (2016). ‘Reputational implications for partners after a major audit failure: Evidence from China’. Journal of Business Ethics, 138, pp. 703-722.
Janney, J. J. and S. Gove (2011). 'Reputation and Corporate social responsibility aberrations, trends, and hypocrisy: Reactions to firm choices in the stock option backdating scandal'. Journal of Management Studies, 48, pp. 1562-1585.
Janssen, C., S. Sen and C. B. Bhattacharya (2015). ‘Corporate crises in the age of corporate social responsibility’. Business Horizons, 58, pp. 183-192.
Johnson, R. A. and D. W. Greening (1999). 'The effects of corporate governance and institutional ownership types on corporate social performance'. Academy of Management Journal, 42, pp. 564-576.
Kaplan, S., J. C. McElroy, S. P. Ravenscroft and C. Shrader (2007). ‘Moral judgements and causal attributions: Consequences of earnings management. Journal of Business Ethics, 74, pp. 149-164.
Karpoff, J. M. and J. R. Jr. Lott (1993). 'The reputational penalty firms bear from committing criminal fraud'. Journal of Law and Economics, 36, pp. 757-802.
Karpoff, J. M., J. R. Jr. Lott and E. W. Wehrly (2005). 'The reputational penalties for environmental violations: Empirical evidence'. Journal of Law and Economics, 48, pp. 653-675.
Karpoff, J. M., S. Lee and G. Martin (2008). 'The cost to firms of cooking the books'. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 43, pp. 581-611.
Kelley, H. H. (1967). 'Attribution theory in social psychology'. In D. Levine (Ed.), Nebraska symposium on motivation (Vol. 15, pp. 192-240). Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
Kelley, H. H. (1972). 'Attribution in social interaction. In E. E. Jones, D. E. Kanouse, H. H. Kelley, R. E. Nisbett, S. Valins and B Weiner (Eds.) Attribution: Perceiving the causes of behavior, pp.1-26. Morristown, NJ: General Learning Press.
Kim, H. J. and G. T. Cameron (2011). ‘Emotions matter in crisis: The role of anger and sadness in the publics’ response to crisis news framing and corporate crisis response’. Communication Research, 38, pp. 826– 855.
Kim, S. (2014). 'What’s worse in times of product-harm crisis? Negative corporate ability or negative CSR reputation?' Journal of Business Ethics, 123, pp. 157-170.
Kölbel, J. F., T. Busch and L. M. Jancso (2017). 'How media coverage of corporate social irresponsibility increases financial risk'. Strategic Management Journal, 38, pp. 2266–2284.
Lange, D. and N. T. Washburn (2012). 'Understanding attributions of corporate social irresponsibility'. Academy of Management Review, 37, pp. 300-326.
Laufer, D. and T. W. Coombs (2006). ‘How should a company respond to a product harm crisis? The role of corporate reputation and consumer-based cues’. Business Horizons, 49, pp. 379-385.
Leavitt, K., L. Zhu and K. Aquino (2016). 'Good without knowing it: Subtle contextual cues can activate moral identity and reshape moral intuition’. Journal of Business Ethics, 137, pp. 785-800.
Lessig, L. (2013). ‘Foreword: “Institutional Corruption” defined’. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 41, pp. 553- 555.
Lin, H., S. Zeng, L. Wang, H. Zou and H. Ma (2016). 'How does environmental irresponsibility impair corporate reputation?' Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 23, pp. 413-423.
Loewenstein, G. (1996). ‘Out of control: Visceral influences on behavior’. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 65, pp. 272-292.
Love, E. G. and M. S. Kraatz (2009). 'Character, conformity, or the bottom line? How and why downsizing affected corporate reputation'. Academy of Management Journal, 52, pp. 314-335.
Love, E. G. and M. S. Kraatz (2017). 'Failed stakeholder exchanges and corporate reputation: The case of earnings misses'. Academy of Management Journal, 60, pp. 880-903.
Love, E. G., J. Lim and M. Bednar (2017). ‘The face of the firm: The influence of CEOs on corporate reputation’. Academy of Management Journal, 60, pp. 1462–1481.
Margolis, J. D. and J. P. Walsh (2003). ‘Misery loves companies: Rethinking social initiatives by business’. Administrative Science Quarterly, 38, pp. 268-305.
Mena, S., J. Rintamäki, P. Fleming and A. Spicer (2016). ‘On the forgetting of corporate irresponsibility’. Academy of Management Review, 41, pp. 720-738.
Minor, D. and J. Morgan (2011). 'CSR as reputation insurance: Primum non Nocere'. California Management Review, 53, pp. 40-59.
Mishina, Y., E. S. Block and M. J. Mannor (2012). 'The path dependence of organizational reputation: How social judgment influences assessments of capability and character'. Strategic Management Journal, 33, pp. 459- 477.
Nordgren, L. F. and M. H. Morris McDonnell (2011). ‘The scope-severity paradox: Why doing more harm is judged to be less harmful’. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 2, pp. 97–102.
Oikonomou, I., C. Brooks and S. Pavelin (2014). ‘The financial effects of uniform and mixed corporate social performance’. Journal of Management Studies, 51, pp. 898–925.
Okhmatovskiy, I. and D. Shin (2018). ‘Changing corporate governance in response to negative media events’. British Journal of Management, 30, pp. 169-187.
Ormiston, M. E. and E. M. Wong (2013). ‘License to ill: The effects of corporate social responsibility and CEO moral identity on corporate social irresponsibility’. Personnel Psychology, 66, pp. 861–893.
Pfarrer, M. D., K. A. Decelles, K. G. Smith and S. M. Taylor (2008). ‘After the fall: Reintegrating the corrupt organization’. Academy of Management Review, 33, pp. 730-749.
Price, J. M. and W. Sun (2017). 'Doing good and doing bad: The impact of corporate social responsibility and irresponsibility on firm performance'. Journal of Business Research, 80, pp. 82-97.
Ravasi, D., V. Rindova., M. Etter and J. Cornelissen. (2018). ‘The formation of organizational reputation’. Academy of Management Annals, 12, pp. 574-599.
Reinecke, J. and S. Ansari (2016). ‘Taming wicked problems: The role of framing in the construction of corporate social responsibility’. Journal of Management Studies, 53, pp. 299-329.
Rhee, M. and P. R. Haunschild (2006). 'The liability of good reputation: A study of product recalls in the U.S. automobile industry'. Organization Science, 17, pp. 101-117.
Rhee, M. and M. E. Valdez (2009). 'Contextual factors surrounding reputation damage with potential implications for reputation repair'. Academy of Management Review, 34, pp. 146-168.
Rim, H., Y. E. Park and D. Song (2018). ‘Watch out when expectancy is violated: An experiment of inconsistent CSR message cueing’. Journal of marketing Communications, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13527266.2018.1523216
Roberts, P. W. and G. R. Dowling (2002). 'Corporate reputation and sustained superior financial performance'. Strategic Management Journal, 23, pp. 1077-1093.
Ryan, L. V. and M. Schneider (2002). 'The antecedents of institutional investor activism'. Academy of Management Review, 27, pp. 554-573.
Shaver, K. G. (1985). 'The attribution of blame: Causality, responsibility, and blameworthiness'. New York: Springer.
Shiu, Y. M. (2017). ‘Does engagement in corporate social responsibility provide strategic insurance-like effects?’. Strategic Management Journal, 38, pp. 455-470.
Sjovall, A. M. and Talk, A. C. (2004). ‘From actions to impressions: Cognitive attribution theory and the formation of corporate reputation’. Corporate Reputation Review, 7, pp. 269-281.
Skilton, P. F. and J. M. Purdy (2017). 'Authenticity, power, and pluralism: A framework for understanding stakeholder critical reviews of corporate social responsibility activities'. Business Ethics Quarterly. 27, pp. 99-123.
Sweetin, V. H., L. L. Knowles, J. H. Summey and K. S. McQueen (2013). 'Willingness-to-punish the corporate brand for corporate social irresponsibility'. Journal of Business Research, 66, pp. 1822-1830.
Tausczik, Y. R. and J. W. Pennebaker (2010). 'The psychological meaning of words: LIWC and computerized text analysis methods'. Journal of Language and Social Psychology, 29, pp. 24-54.
Tucker, L. and T. C. Melewar (2005). Corporate Reputation and Crisis Management: The Threat and Manageability of Anti-corporatism. Corporate Reputation Review. 7, pp. 377-387.
Vanhamme, J. and B. Grobben (2009). '“Too Good to be True!”. The effectiveness of CSR history in countering negative publicity'. Journal of Business Ethics, 85, pp. 273-283.
Voliotis, S., P. A. Vlachos and O. Epitropaki (2016). ‘Perception-induced effects of corporate social irresponsibility (CSiR) for stereotypical and admired firms’. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, 970-976.
Wagner, T., R. J. Lutz and B. A. Weitz (2009). 'Corporate hypocrisy: Overcoming the threat of inconsistent corporate social responsibility perceptions'. Journal of Marketing, 73, pp. 77-91.
Walker, K. A. (2010). 'A systematic review of the corporate reputation literature: Definition, measurement, and theory'. Corporate Reputation Review, 12, pp. 357-387.
Walker, M., B. Heere, M. M. Parent and D. Drane (2010). 'Social responsibility and the Olympic Games: The mediating role of consumer attributions'. Journal of Business Ethics, 93, pp. 1-22.
Walker, K., Z. Zhang, Z. and N. Ni (2018). 'The mirror effect: Corporate social responsibility, corporate social irresponsibility and firm performance in coordinated market economies and liberal market economies'. British Journal of Management. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.12271.
Walley, N and B. Whitehead (1994). ‘It's not easy being green’. Harvard Business Review, 72, pp. 46-52.
Wei, J. C., Z. Ouyang, Z. and H. P. Chen (2017). 'Well known or well liked? The effects of corporate reputation on firm value at the onset of a corporate crisis'. Strategic Management Journal, 38, pp. 2103-2120.
Weick, K. E., K. M. Sutcliffe and Obstfeld, D. (2005). 'Organizing and the process of sensemaking'. Organization Science, 16, pp. 327-451.
Weiner, B., S. Graham and C. Chandler (1982). ‘Pity, anger, and guilt: An attributional analysis’. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 8, pp. 226–232.
West, B., C. Hillenbrand, K. Money, A. Ghobadian and D. R. Ireland (2016). ‘Exploring the impact of social axioms on firm reputation: A stakeholder perspective’. British Journal of Management, 27, pp. 249-270.
Yoon, Y., Z. Gürhan-Canli, Z. and N. Schwarz (2006). 'The effect of corporate social responsibility (CSR) activities on companies with bad reputations'. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 16, pp. 377-390.
Zavyalova, A., M. D. Pfarrer, R. K. Reger and T. D. Hubbard (2016). 'Reputation as a benefit and a burden? How stakeholders’ organizational identification affects the role of reputation following a negative event'. Academy of Management Journal, 59, pp. 253-276.
Zyglidopoulos, S. C. (2001). 'The impact of accidents on firms' reputation for social performance'. Business & Society, 40, pp. 416-432.
Zyglidopoulos, S. C., A. P. Georgiadis, C. E. Carroll and D. S. Siegel (2012). ‘Does media attention drive corporate social responsibility?’. Journal of Business Research, 11, pp. 1622-1627. University Staff: Request a correction | Centaur Editors: Update this record |